Is it Really So Difficult to Improve One's Golf Swing?

Perhaps like you, I have struggled with this wonderfuladvances in golf course maintenance and course
game of golf most of my life. An avid reader andconditions.
student of the game, I tried countless tips andI for one, take issue with Witter's analogy and his
numerous training aids, all with little help. There is a golfconclusion. I did start as a hacker at about age 30. Not
cartoon floating around that depicts a golfer taking aa good age to start such a difficult sport because
swing, with the club in several different positions.according to physiologists, my body had already
Around the golfer, and using up every bit of whitereached or was soon to reach its peak physical
space, the cartoonist wrote in 52 tips or techniques ofcondition. My handicap remained around 19 for a good
which he was aware. If space allowed, he could havepart of my life. Finally at age 65, I shot a 78 and have
added others. The cartoon simply reminds us howshot rounds in the 70's several times since. To what
difficult the swing can actually be.can I attribute my improvement and how does the law
Not so surprising, most of the tips were arguable. Itof entropy apply, if at all?
was not until I focused on two unarguable aspects ofThere is no doubt in my mind that improvement came
the swing did my game improve and did I finally breakabout because I began to focus on keeping my head
80 at age 65. I am not a good athlete like a Michaelbehind the ball through impact and by maintaining my
Jordan, who is still struggling with his game. But with aspine angle. My study of the game lead me to the
focus on these two aspects, it is my belief that thereconclusion that at least these two aspects of the golf
is hope for all golfers at any age.swing were unarguable. To incorporate this change
Within my readings, I recently came across a golfinto my swing was now the challenge. I knew enough
article simply entitled Entropy, by Ben Witter andabout muscle memory and neuromuscular training to
published in "Essays on the Future of Golf". Holding arealize any change to my swing required feedback, if
mechanical engineering degree myself, I wonderedsuch change was to become consistent, repeatable,
what "entropy" could have to do with golf. Here ismemorized and ultimately executed unconsciously.
what Witter wrote. "The second law ofAt my age I knew also that time was not on my side. I
thermodynamics states that all objects in the universedid not have the time to get sufficient feedback from
are subject to entropy, meaning that they will all revertplaying enough rounds of golf, or by hitting hundreds of
back to their original form and shape unless actedballs at a driving range or by taking numerous lessons
upon by an outside energy." Applied to golfingfrom the same Pro. I somehow had to get frequent
proficiency, Witter writes:" If you began golf as aand instantaneous tactile feedback on these two
hacker and you work on becoming better, youraspects to change and improve my swing. And so I
destinations toward becoming a hacker again isdid with a full swing training device that I designed and
inevitable. It is actually a physical law of the universe."built. Lo and behold the 80 barrier was broken.
Evidence to support his conclusion is offered byAs for the law of entropy, if in fact it does apply, my
comparing and reviewing USGA indices from golfonly explanation is that the forces exerted by my
clubs across the country, over the past 50 years,body, coupled with the training device, might have
wherein golf handicaps have remained about theprovided that "outside energy" that enabled me to
same. This statistic is astounding because of the factdelay the inevitable journey to again becoming a
that there have been huge advances in equipmenthacker. For me, golf is fun.
technology, advances in instructional technology, and