Teens, Jobs and School: The Pros and Cons

Most teens realize at a fairly young age the old adagework longer hours than those in a typical school day.
that "money equals power." Money equals designerAnd the right job may provide networking possibilities
clothes, a car and insurance, and in many cases, aand set your child on a rewarding lifetime career path.
certain amount of freedom. And in order to get money,But before your child gets a job, there are some things
many teens get part-time jobs.you should know. According to the Pennsylvania
While the benefits and/or drawbacks of teens andDepartment of Labor and Industry, "Minors under 14
part-time jobs have been researched, studied andyears of age may not be employed or permitted to
debated since at least 1979, the teens, jobs andwork in any occupation, except children employed on
affects on schoolwork verdict is still out. According tofarms or in domestic service in private homes."
the U.S. Department of Labor, 50 percent of AmericanChildren under the age of 14 can also work on farms,
teenagers hold informal jobs, such as babysitting orbe golf caddies, newspaper carriers or juvenile
yard work, by age 12. And by age 15, nearly two-thirdsperformers in the entertainment industry. But special
of American teens have had some kind ofpermits may need to be required.
employment. And many researchers, including those onAlso according to many state labor laws, teens aged
government panels like the National Commission on14 and 15 are not permitted to work more than four
Youth praise part-time work and say it contributes tohours per day during the school year and not before 7
the transition from youth to adulthood.a.m. or after 7 p.m. (During the summer, the amount of
Parents and educators alike have, for decades, saidhours of work per day can be increased to eight.)
that part-time jobs teach children how to beChildren under the age of 16 are prohibited, by
responsible and manage money. But Temple UniversityPennsylvania law, for example, from working in bowling
researcher Laurence Steinberg found that only 11centers (unless as snack bar attendants, scorers or
percent of students report saving most of their moneycontrol desk clerks), building heavy work, highway
for college, and only three percent contribute towork, anywhere liquor is sold or dispensed,
household living expenses. "The bulk of teen's moneymanufacturing, on scaffolds or ladders and window
goes to clothing, cars, entertainment, and in somecleaning.
cases, drugs and alcohol," according to results of aFor 16 and 17 year olds, the some state laws say,
study published in Harvard Education Letter in 1998."minors are not to work before 6 a.m. or after midnight
Steinberg says, "Students who work longer hourson school days and 1 a.m. on Fridays and Saturdays."
report diminished engagement in schooling, loweredAlso, not more than eight hours per day and 28 hours
school performance, increased psychological distress,per school week. (During the summer, the only
higher drug and alcohol use, higher rates of delinquencyrestrictions on 16 and 17 year olds, is that they can
and greater autonomy from parental control." A 1997work no more than eight hours per day or 44 hours
study by David Stern, director of the Nationalper week.) Young adults under the age of 18 are
Research Center for Vocational Education at theprohibited from working in billiard rooms; doing electrical
University of California, Berkeley, proves Steinberg'swork; operating elevators; performing crane and
viewpoint. In research conducted over 20 years,hoisting operations; excavating; operating machinery
students who worked more than 15 hours per weekthat does woodworking, bakery mixing, cleaning, oiling
had lower grades, did less homework, had higheror punch pressing; roofing; welding; and doing demolition.
dropout rates and were less likely to go to college thanYour teen securing a job is a big step on the road to
students who worked under 15 hours per week.maturity. Be sure to discuss the pros and the cons
But Jerald Bachman at the University of Michigan'swith him or her. You may also want to agree to a job
Monitoring the Future Project, warns not to jump toon a trial basis, such as "you can work x number of
cause and effect conclusions. "I would argue that mosthours a week this grading period and then we will
of the problems that correlate with working long hoursdecide if you can keep working, based on your
are more fundamentally caused," he says. "That maygrades." Maintaining good grades, continuing extra
contribute the to spiral, but I think the spiral is wellcurricular activities and keeping a social life will be
underway at the time they elect to work the longimportant to your child's psychological health and
hours."development. Also, prepare a budget with your child,
Though the drawbacks to a busy, part-time job aresetting limits on spending and enforcing a
many, so are the benefits. A teenager's job can teachpercentage-of- paycheck-into-savings policy. Good
work skills that school does not, and it can instill in themoney management skills, acquired when young, will
teen new confidence, sense of responsibility andlast a lifetime. Part-time jobs can be a wonderful
independence. Earning money will enable your teen toexperience, with the right supervision and parental
buy things and to manage money. An after-school jobguidance.
can also provide adult supervision, especially if you